Emotional Tactics: Recognizing and Responding to Manipulation in Your Child

Dealing with a manipulative child? Stay calm, acknowledge feelings, and carry on, suggest the experts.

Yes, children sometimes try to manipulate their parents with their emotions. While research affirms this truth ⁱ, it’s important to understand exactly what’s going on with your child and why.

Interactions between children and parents can be incredibly complex, evolving as the child matures. In my doctoral research on identity formation and child development, I’ve observed how children often vacillate between expressing their real, conscious needs and resorting to more subtle, subconscious emotional manipulations to get simply what they want, without understanding what they actually need. This ebb and flow can be tricky to navigate.

The challenge for dads is to discern when emotions signal a true need versus when they are being used as a tool to manipulate a situation. And let’s be clear—not every emotional outburst from a child warrants accommodation. In fact, constantly giving in only enables undesirable behavior.

When manipulation is at play, it’s crucial for dads to stay calm, grounded, and curious, digging deeper to understand the true issue behind the emotional outburst. Here are some key things to remember when navigating these moments with your child:

1. Dad Rule #4,253: “The Issue is Rarely the Issue”
In other words, during emotional outbursts and meltdowns, try not to get caught up in the immediate emotion. Step back and look deeper. Often, what’s being expressed on the surface isn’t the actual issue. Whether it's frustration, anger, or tears, children may be reacting to something more complex—maybe fear, insecurity, or an unmet need they can’t yet articulate. The goal is to uncover the root cause of their behavior, not just react to the emotion itself.

2. Don’t Dismiss the Emotion or Your Child
As frustrating as it can be, the first thing you should do when your child is upset is to pause and listen. Validate their feelings, even if you don't fully understand them or agree with them. Acknowledge that they're feeling something, because their feelings are real to them. That doesn't mean you have to give in to whatever they want in the moment, but it does mean showing them that you're paying attention to their emotional world. Sometimes, the issue is a physical need (hunger, tiredness, discomfort), or an emotional need (wanting attention, reassurance, or affection).

3. What Your Child Needs Isn’t Always What They Want
This is a big one. Children, especially younger ones, often express their needs through what they want. They might want a toy, a treat, or a specific outcome. But what they really need might be something different—more attention, connection, affirmation, or structure. Sometimes, they might even need discipline, boundaries, or consequences. Loving your child doesn’t always mean giving them what they ask for, but it does mean giving them what they truly need, even if it’s uncomfortable for both of you.

4. Teach Your Child to Express Needs and Feelings Appropriately
All emotions are valid and should be acknowledged, but not all ways of expressing those emotions are appropriate. It’s important for children to learn how to express their emotions in more healthy, appropriate ways. While a meltdown or outburst may be their immediate reaction, they need to be taught how to identify and express their feelings calmly and respectfully. This is a life skill they’ll carry into adulthood. If they’re never taught how to regulate their emotions or how to express their needs without manipulation, they’ll struggle with emotional intelligence and communication later on.

5. Don’t Completely Dismiss Emotions—Give an Outlet for Expression
While it's important to teach your child emotional regulation, it’s equally important not to completely shut down their emotional expressions. If we dismiss or ignore their feelings, we risk raising adults who are disconnected from their own emotions or uncomfortable with emotional intimacy. Children need a safe space to express their feelings, even if those feelings are difficult or inconvenient for us to hear. By acknowledging their emotions without judgment, we create a foundation of trust and open communication.

6. Show Grace—Everyone Has Bad Days
Finally, remember that, just like adults, kids have bad days too. Expecting your child to always express their emotions perfectly or never have a moment of frustration is unrealistic. Not even adults do well at this! Children are still learning to navigate the world of emotions, and their ability to do so will evolve over time. Show grace when your child struggles, but also maintain firm boundaries and consistency. Be empathetic to their struggles, even if you need to correct their behavior. The key is to approach emotional moments from a place of empathy and stability—showing them that it’s okay to feel upset, but also teaching them how to process and move through those feelings in a healthy way.

When children attempt to manipulate us with emotions, it can be frustrating and challenging. However, by staying calm, acknowledging their feelings, and responding with clarity, dads can help their children navigate these emotional moments without giving in to manipulation. By distinguishing between genuine needs and emotional ploys, and by teaching children healthy ways to express and manage their emotions, fathers can foster emotional intelligence, resilience, and respect in their kids. Above all, remember: your ability to stay steady, secure, and empathetic is one of the most powerful tools you have in your parenting toolkit.

Want more information about managing your child’s emotional outbursts? See my article “4 STRATEGIES TO HANDLE A MELTDOWN WITH EMPATHY”

I'd love your feedback! Do you agree? What are your strategies for handling outbursts from your children? Email me. I read every response.

Mike Ayers, Ph.D.

______________________

ⁱ Research accessed:

Is My Young Child Manipulating Me? Medically reviewed by Akilah Reynolds, PhD — Written by Karen Sosnoski, PhD. https://psychcentral.com/relationships/is-my-young-child-manipulating-me.

Emotional Extortion: How Adolescents Manipulate Parents. Carl E Pickhardt Ph.D. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/surviving-your-childs-adolescence/200909/emotional-extortion-how-adolescents-manipulate

Does Your Child Act Out to Manipulate You? How to Stop Falling for It. Debbie Pincus, MS LMHC. https://www.empoweringparents.com/article/does-your-child-act-out-to-manipulate-you-how-to-stop-falling-for-it/

How to help kids understand and manage their emotions. Kirsten Weir.
https://www.apa.org/topics/parenting/emotion-regulation

Masters of Manipulation: How Kids Control You With Behavior. James Lehman, MSW. https://www.empoweringparents.com/article/masters-of-manipulation-how-kids-control-you-with-behavior/

Manipulative Child Behavior Symptoms: Recognizing and Addressing the Signs. https://neurolaunch.com/manipulative-child-behavior-symptoms/